Shopping Cart
Your Cart is Empty
Quantity:
Subtotal
Taxes
Shipping
Total
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should be receiving an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Cart

COOKIE CONUNDRUM

Sugar Cookies

Plain Sugar Cookies

Melt in your mouth, buttery goodness, plain and simple.

$2 ea

6 for $10

12 for $20

1

GF Plain Sugar Cookies (min order 1 dz)

12 for $25

Mini Iced Sugar Cookies (min order 1 dz)

Smaller version of our plain sugar cookie finished off with royal icing.

12 for $24

GF Mini Iced Sugar Cookies (min order 1 dz)

12 for $29

Iced Sugar Cookies

Full size version of our plain sugar cookie finished off with royal icing.

$3.00 ea

6 for $18

12 for $35

GF Iced Sugar Cookies (min order 1 dz)

12 for $40

Custom Sugar Cookies

Iced Sugar Cookies

3-4 signature sugar cookie designs custom decorated with royal icing in 3-4 colors. Submit request for quote.

(min order 1 dz)

Start at $40/dz


Non-Sugar Cookies

Cinco C

Colossal Caramel Chocolate Chip Cookie filled with pecans, caramel chips, dark chocolate chips & milk chocolate chips. 

$2 ea

6 for $10

12 for $20

Trail Boss

Soft baked oatmeal cookie full of fruits and nuts plus a hint of sweetness from a variety of chocolate chips.

$2 ea

6 for $10

12 for $20

Nana Puddin' Cookie

Banana flavored sugar cookie filled with marshmallows and nilla wafer bits and rolled in brown sugar for a caramelized coating.

$2 ea

6 for $10

12 for $20

Peanut Butter Bliss

Good old fashioned peanut butter cookie, complete with fork tine "hashtag".

$2 ea

6 for $10

12 for $20

Biscotti

A variety of flavors (as available) including Classic Almond, Dark Chocolate Dipped Classic Almond and Caramel Cappuccino. 

$2 ea

6 for $10

12 for $20

Shortbreads

Pecan Shortbread

Think pecan sandie - light and buttery and the perfect companion to a hot cup of herbal tea.

6 for $6

12 for $12

Dandelion Shortbread (available seasonally)

Same buttery shortbread base as above but with freshly harvested Dandelion petals lending a fresh taste and light texture.

6 for $6

12 for $12

Pistachio Rose Shortbread (available seasonally)

Same buttery shortbread base as above but with freshly harvested rose petals and chopped pistachios.

6 for $6

12 for $12

Order Now

Other Items

The Peacemaker

An assortment of six cookies, to include one each of the following: Cinco C, Trail Boss, Peanut Butter Bliss, Nana Puddin' Cookie, Biscotti, Signature Iced Sugar Cookie.

$12

Triple Nut Dark Chocolate Granola

8 oz of freshly baked granola made with old fashioned oats, pecans, walnuts, almonds, dark chocolate. (Contains honey and coconut oil)

$5

The Bexar Bones (dog treats)

24 dog treats that combine the flavors of peanut butter and pumpkin, taste-tested and approved by our own lab/shepherd mix, Bexar.

$10

Payment types accepted:

@Elizabeth-Simmons-82

$bethannetx

Contact us to prepay

via credit card

Pay to the order of

Cookie Conundrum

Cash